Therapy Session: Playoff Kryptonite
An in depth look into the Packers playoff losses since 2011 majority from this specific division.

Green Bay’s overall playoff record since their 2010 Super Bowl run is 8-11. Here are the Packers last 11 playoff losses:
2011 New York Giants 37-20, NFC East.
2012 San Francisco 49ers 45-31, NFC West.
2013 San Francisco 49ers 23-20, NFC West.
2014 Seattle Seahawks 28-22 OT, NFC West.
2015 Arizona Cardinals 26-20 OT, NFC West.
2016 Atlanta Falcons 44-21, NFC South.
2019 San Francisco 49ers 37-20, NFC West.
2020 Tampa Bay Buccaneers 31-26, NFC South.
2021: San Francisco 49ers 13-10,NFC West.
2023: San Francisco 49ers 24-21, NFC West.
2024: Philadelphia Eagles 22-10, NFC East.
What Stands Out?
Brutal, right? Besides the pain of reminiscing on these losses reflecting on how many potential Super Bowl Packer teams came up short, there is one division that seems to stand out in having Green Bay’s number. The NFC West has seven victories while the rest of the divisions combined have a total of four.
In an attempt for some positivity, one thing that the Packers can take pride in is being 3-0 against the Dallas Cowboys in this time frame without losing to a division rival. However, they have only played the Vikings from the NFC North and that was in 2012 winning 24-10 when Minnesota’s starting QB was backup Joe Webb (FB John Kuhn had two touchdowns).
NFC West AKA Green Bay's Kryptonite
“Alexa, play Kryptonite by 3 Doors Down.” From the frustration of losing in overtime to the heartbreak of special team blunders when it matters most, the NFC West has been a nightmare matchup for the Packers in the playoffs. Green Bay’s overall record against the NFC West since 2011 is 2-7 with their only wins happening in 2019 against Seattle and 2020 against the Los Angeles Rams.
In playoff matchups against each other, the NFC West averages 28 points per game while the Packers averages 20.6 points per game. That is a touchdown and a two point conversion of a difference with each game containing vivid memories as to why Green Bay ultimately loss:
- 2012 against the 49ers division round, QB Collin Kaepernick eats the Packers’ defense alive throwing 17-31 on 232 yards and 2 touchdowns while rushing for 181 yards with 2 touchdowns.
- 2013 against the 49ers wild card round, K Phil Dawson makes 3 field goals including the game winner as time expires with QB Kaepernick out performing QB Aaron Rodgers.
- 2014 against the Seahawks NFC Championship, Packers lead 19-7 with 3 minutes left as QB Russel Wilson leads a miracle comeback at Lambeau with the botched onside kick recovery and special teams two point conversion blunder.
- 2015 against the Arizona Cardinals division round, back-to-back miracle Hail Mary throws by QB Rodgers including the game tying touchdown to WR Jeff Janis leading to WR Larry Fitzgerald going berserk in overtime with the game winning touchdown. (Packers offense did not touch the field in OT).
- 2019 against the 49ers NFC Championship, RB Raheem Mostert turns into RB Barry Sanders rushing for 220 yards on 29 carries with 4 touchdowns.
- 2021 against the 49ers division round, how does RB Aaron Jones not score on that run? Blocked punt leading to a touchdown as Green Bay’s offense turns stagnant losing in heartbreaking fashion on a K Robbie Gould game winning field goal in snowy Lambeau Field.
- 2023 against the 49ers division round, K Anders Carlson misses a crucial field goal in the fourth quarter leading to a game winning touchdown by RB Christian McCaffrey as QB Jordan Love throws a game ending interception.
Sometimes it is good to reflect, however reminiscing on these losses can be equivalently painful to a massive hangover. The Packers have got to find a way to beat the NFC West, specifically the San Francisco 49ers, when it matters most and get the monkey off its back. The loss that hurts the most in my opinion is the 2021 division round against San Francisco. Which loss do you feel the same way about?
PLEASE SUBSCRIBE TO OUR CHEESEHEAD NATION WEEKLY NEWSLETTER HERE.
__________________________
Mitchell Adams is a passionate lifelong Packer fan bringing a unique West Coast perspective, and also produces multiple podcast platforms, is a published author, and a proud Packers shareholder. Follow him on X at @mitchadams209.
__________________________




Comments (29)
Leatherhead
April 08, 2025 at 02:35 pm
The 2014 Seattle game was not played at Lambeau.
SF has had our number. You could go back to 1998 and Terrell Owens' miracle reception.
SF has a good organization. They usually put a good team on the field and they're never bad for long. IMO, they've done the best job in the NFC over the last 15 years or so.
[XXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
We've averaged 20.6 ppg in head-to-heads with NFC West teams in the playoffs.?? I did not know that, but it doesn't surprise me. We consistently do not score enough points in elimination games. Look back for as many years as you'd like and you'll see that scoring less than 21 points in a playoff game will end your season most of the time. Most of the time, the winning team in the playoffs has at least 27 points, so if you aren't getting to 27, you're really not giving yourself a very good chance to win.
LeotisHarris
April 08, 2025 at 08:09 pm
"SF has had our number. You could go back to 1998 and Terrell Owens' miracle reception."
JERRY RICE FUMBLED!
LLCHESTY
April 08, 2025 at 09:00 pm
You're damn right he did!!😡
KenEllis
April 08, 2025 at 09:01 pm
Playing in the weak NFC North made Packer teams look stronger than they really were over the 13 seasons before last season, and even last season the mighty NFC North went 0-3 in the playoffs.
Only 2 NFC North teams have even made it to the Super Bowl this century and none since the Pack went 15 years ago.
GB used to regularly be better than the Bears, Vikes, and Lions but we haven't won the North since 2021 and so we can't even claim that anymore.
Oh well, Gutey has announced it is time for some urgency so I'm sure good times are right around the corner.
splitpea1
April 08, 2025 at 03:41 pm
San Francisco generally had the more physical and better defensive teams during this stretch--a lesson that maybe should be absorbed from the current regime in Green Bay.
We played them pretty tough in 2021. Most of this game was the highlight of Joe Barry's stint here--until as usual, the defense wilted in the final drive. Unfortunately special teams, which had been a big problem all season, saved it's worst for the biggest game. And our MVP quarterback was so locked in on Davante that he missed an open receiver on the offense's final drive.
Both home playoff losses to the 49ers were played in frigid conditions, and since the warm-weather visitors had no problem winning, I hope I don't have to read any more articles with the allusion that we somehow have an advantage in the bitter cold.
Take your pick of which one was the worst, but there's not a strong enough word for the embarrassment when you give up 181 rushing yards to the QB. On Kaepernick's 56-yard TD scamper, the Packers' defense wasn't even looking for it, even though he had taken off all game. Horrible.
barutanseijin
April 08, 2025 at 06:13 pm
You’re going to complain about the defense in that 2021 game? The offense left them hanging with a totally miserable game, especially the overrated, over-the-hill quarterback. 10 points? That’s hardly ever going to do the job.
LLCHESTY
April 08, 2025 at 09:07 pm
The Marcedes Lewis fumble really killed their momentum, more than it should've. Crosby's gimme miss didn't help either.
TarynsEyes
April 08, 2025 at 03:52 pm
I have no nightmares about any of the losses, what does give me nightmares is the exorbitant number of brain farts committed by HC, players, and the taking off nearly a month before having to play the Giants when going for back-to-back SB victories. Some may argue, but I believe every one of those games were wins, until the wtf moments of stupidity came from the head that they apparent decided to stick up their arses.
nagawicka
April 08, 2025 at 06:10 pm
Hey Mitchell Adams,
Here's a fun one -- Now do a statistical analysis relating Brett Favre Interceptions (BFI) to the Pack's sudden exit from one seemingly functional playoff run after another. Promising run or not, Favre INTs were THE coffin nail every time: 4 INTs vs Minny, 2 vs. Pitt, 2 vs Atlanta I think six against the Rams--and that's not the half of it. Keep looking, and again and again and again the Packers' playoff run hit a brick wall in the form of multiple Brett Favre interceptions. Like, 3 or more.
Which is wild b/c every game in that Packers-Cowboys rivalry was determined by whether Favre threw one interception or two, and/or whether Aikman threw none (most of the time) or one (not often enough). The hair by which Michael Irvin prevailed every game, also.
Against *that* backdrop, where beating Aikman meant staying in control, playing within the scheme, moving the chains, Favre loses it in the final game and the season splatters in a handful of INTs. That's why Reggie WHite turned this team around.
Worth a column.
Leatherhead
April 08, 2025 at 06:37 pm
People hate it when I say this, but Brett Favre was the biggest big game liability in NFL history, and nobody else is even close.
A friend told me that we should market a calender where we rename December and call it "interception", because that's how every year ended.
2001, 6 interceptions 2002...multiple turnovers 2003....the horrible overtime pick. 2004....multiple turnovers. And a final horrible pick in 2007. Then he went to Minnesota, where he threw their season away.
Favre had many abilities, but he did not protect the ball in the big moments. That's a fact, it's part of his legacy. Great arm, unparalleled durability, colorful character, but not a guy who delivered in the clutch.
ThunderFromDownunder
April 09, 2025 at 04:27 am
What about the best INT Farve threw .... the one that sank the Vikings and stopped them going to the SB . LOL
NFLfan
April 08, 2025 at 06:28 pm
I vividly remember the play-off game against SF in 2021. Rodgers did attempt to spread the ball around but Lazard, Cobb and Lewis dropped important passes; accurate, perfect passes bounced off the chests of Cobb and Lewis.
Rodgers likely made a decision to target a more reliable receiver (who was double-covered) than risk another drop.
Leatherhead
April 08, 2025 at 06:39 pm
That's not his job. His job is to execute the offense. If he throws it to an open guy who drops it, that's on the receiver. If he forces the ball to a receiver who is covered because he doesn't "trust" them, then he's contravening the coaches who put him out there.
Rodgers: 20-29 for 196 yards. AT home. A QBR rating of 57.9
NFLfan
April 10, 2025 at 08:08 am
Rodgers did run the Offense because neither McCarthy nor MLF were his equal football IQ-wise. My guess is Rodgers longed for a coach who was smarter than him-perhaps an Andy Reid. And, he had 1 competent receiver.
13TimeChamps
April 10, 2025 at 10:39 am
I wouldn't consider throwing very low percentage deep throws to a covered receiver while ignoring open receivers to pick up 1st downs that would keep the chains moving as having a high football IQ.
13TimeChamps
April 10, 2025 at 10:50 am
"My guess is Rodgers longed for a coach who was smarter than him."
Is it also your guess that Rodgers thought Nathaniel Hackett was smarter than him? The guy that Rodgers insisted he be his OC in NY. The guy who now basically is an unemployed laughingstock in the NFL.
My "guess" would be that he wanted someone he could control, so he could pretty much run his own offense.
NFLfan
April 10, 2025 at 11:53 am
Rodgers, his receivers and Bakh ran the team in GB. It worked for many years in a soft division during the regular season. Rodgers became who he is now because he had to carry the team and put up points. GB wasted his talent w/ chronically under-performing Defenses, ST's, and not drafting decent receivers in the Gute era. I'm certain he wanted a smarter coach (s). McCarthy cannot find a job in the current NFL-the market has spoken. Don't think MLF would be in high demand either.
13TimeChamps
April 10, 2025 at 12:30 pm
I understand your silly crush on Rodgers. You're certainly not the only one.
How exactly are you "certain" he wanted smarter coaches? He's undermined every HC that he has had.
But you lose all credibility when you question a coach's football IQ who has been a head coach in the NFL for 18 years, who has won 185 games, including a Super Bowl, and devised one of the most potent offenses (2011) in NFL history.
As far as MLF, if he became available next offseason, he would probably be the first to get a new job.
Look, you're not a Packers fan, you're not really even an NFL fan. You're an unabashed Aaron Rodgers fan. Like most obsessions, this will pass in time.
NFLfan
April 13, 2025 at 01:08 pm
It is obvious you take hits at me anytime you can.
I am interested in telling the truth and am a fan and wish GB could rid themselves of mediocre coaches and fans who are apologists.
Leatherhead
April 10, 2025 at 11:17 am
So the only coach that Rodgers could play for is Andy Reid? Fascinating. You do realize that McCarthy is probably going to the HOF?
Bitternotsour
April 10, 2025 at 11:45 am
McCarthy is definitely going to be inducted to the HOF.
Bitternotsour
April 10, 2025 at 11:48 am
It's laughable to me that people think Aaron Rodgers is smart. perhaps for an average football player he is smart, but in the world at large, AR is what stupid people think smart is.
LeotisHarris
April 08, 2025 at 09:24 pm
Time can dim memories.
2021 Divisional Round
Green Bay Receiving
Aaron Jones 9 Rec on 10 Targets - 129 yards
Davante Adams 9 Rec on 11 Targets - 90 yards
Allen Lazard 1 Rec on 1 Target - 6 yards
Marcedes Lewis 1 Rec on 1 Target - 0 yards
Randall Cobb 0 Rec on 1 Target
LeotisHarris
April 08, 2025 at 07:57 pm
"In playoff matchups against each other, the NFC West averages 28 points per game while the Packers averages 20.6 points per game. That is a touchdown and a two point conversion of a difference with each game containing vivid memories as to why Green Bay ultimately loss:"
Grammarly is *still* free, Mitchell.
In playoff matchups, the NFC West averaged 28 points per game while the Packers averaged 20.6. (you could let the reader do the math, but you are dealing with American readers primarily, so it was good of you to break the differential down into a easily understood quantity). Each game still evokes vivid memories of how Green Bay ultimately lost:
LLCHESTY
April 08, 2025 at 09:12 pm
Whoa, the anti Grammer police are letting their views be shown!🤣
mjbrogno
April 09, 2025 at 08:54 am
I was at the 1998 and 2012 losses to the Entitlement team, brutal to say the least. Let’s not forget that J. Rice fumbled on the drive leading to the Owen’s TD. What I remember most about both those losses were the obnoxious, disrespectful 49er fans. I’m a Jersey guy born and raised and will not back down to anyone that is so disrespectful as were the 49er fans.
As I was leaving the 2012 game a 49er fan was ready to spit on my nephew, I put an immediate stop to it, nothing physical, just a strong verbal warning. As we were walking out side the stadium an elderly woman was walking in front of me wearing a cheesehead. Some punk walked by her and knocked it off her head. At this point I had enough of this unruly behavior. As I turned to grab this idiot, an older 49er fan grabbed this jerk before I could and made him pick up the lady’s cheesehead and made him apologize to the lady. He verbally ripped him a new one. Yes, I know that there are jerks and idiots in all fan bases, but it’s just a game. Go Pack Go !!!
HarryHodag
April 09, 2025 at 11:11 am
The turning point for me was the loss in January, 2003 when Atlanta came to Green Bay in the cold and won 27-7. They couldn't stop Michael Vick. Up until that time you felt the Packers could win anything at home. Other than the Super Bowl season it seemed the Packers kept coming up short in the playoffs.
Another was the sub-zero night time playoff game in Green Bay when the Giants simply ran over the Packers.
My take: toughness. Regardless of whether it was Mike Sherman, Mike McCarthy or Matt LF the team always seems to fall to teams who bring their play to a new level during the playoffs.. I remember the quote from Ron Wolf when he came to Green Bay and thought it was like a 'country club'. I sometimes wonder if things are a bit too comfy. Lombardi and Holmgren never tolerated comfort.
I would love to see Green Bay kick some team to the curb and ask for seconds. It's been awhile since that happened.
Leatherhead
April 10, 2025 at 09:48 am
'''The turning point for me was the loss in January, 2003 when Atlanta came to Green Bay in the cold and won 27-7. They couldn't stop Michael Vick'''
This is perfect. We score 7 points and our memory is we couldn't stop the other team. Favre had two picks and a rating of 54.4 , but the problem is we couldn't stop. We lost three fumbles, but the problem is we couldn't stop the other team.
So we drafted a linebacker, and then blamed him the next year when the Eagles completed a 4th and 26 while we were scoring 17.
Am I the only person that sees this? Every year, the offense shits the bed in the playoffs and we remember a defense that couldn't stop.
S
BuckyBadger
April 10, 2025 at 07:26 am
Packers always get bullied in the playoffs.