Seven XFL Players Who Make Sense For the Packers
The minor league is an important tool to evaluate players

The existence of football minor leagues is an important step for players to get new chances in the NFL. But it's also relevant for NFL front offices, who get more opportunities to scout players on the field. Last year, the Green Bay Packers signed multiple players from the USFL: TE Sal Cannella, WR Osirus Mitchell, WR Ishmael Hyman, S Micah Abernathy, RB Dexter Williams, and K Ramiz Ahmed.
While the second season of the USFL hasn't started yet, the XFL is going to the eighth week of the regular season — there are 10 weeks, plus two postseason weeks.
Let's take a look at XFL players who could help the Packers and try to make the 53-man roster.
QB AJ McCarron, St. Louis BattleHawks
When the Packers trade Aaron Rodgers to the New York Jets, it'll be imperative to add a backup quarterback. McCarron has extensive NFL experience, where he's played for the Cincinnati Bengals, Buffalo Bills, Oakland Raiders, Houston Texans, and Atlanta Falcons. He decided to play in the XFL to allow his children to watch him on the field, but he certainly still has the ability to be in an NFL camp. He leads the XFL in touchdowns and TD:INT ratio, and is second in passing yards.
RB Abram Smith, DC Defenders
The former Baylor running back was undrafted last season and spent the training camp with the New Orleans Saints. He is still young, 24 years old. He leads the XFL in rushing yards, yards per run among players with at least 20 attempts, and scores. For the Defenders, he's had 654 yards in 121 runs and six touchdowns.
WR Hakeem Butler, St. Louis BattleHawks
Butler was a promising young player, but didn't live up to expectations in his first chances in the NFL. He spent just one season with the Arizona Cardinals after being drafted in the fourth round in 2019. Butler had smaller opportunities for the Carolina Panthers, Philadelphia Eagles (where he even tried a transition to tight end), and in the CFL. In the XFL, he's been a primary target for McCarron, and he's been able to apply his big body and physicality to generate production. He is tied for first in receiving touchdowns (5) and is fifth in receiving yards.
TE Sal Cannella, Arlington Renegades
Well, we know the Packers like Cannella because they signed him last preseason after he was a 1st-team All-USFL, and he was better than Tyler Davis in a small sample size. He didn't make the roster or the practice squad, though, and came back to the minor leagues. Now, he's again playing like an NFL tight end. He leads the XFL in receiving yards, targets, and receptions among tight ends — if we consider Cody Latimer as a wide receiver. Taking into consideration how thin the Packers depth is at the position, it makes sense to give Cannella another chance.
EDGE Trent Harris, Houston Roughnecks
Harris has played under Wade Phillips in a classic 3-4 scheme with the Houston Roughnecks, and he leads the XFL in sacks, with seven in six games. He's also tied for first in tackles for loss, which shows how frequently he's in the opposing backfield. Harris is 27 and has played in the NFL for the New England Patriots, Miami Dolphins, New York Giants, Baltimore Ravens, and Las Vegas Raiders.
S Sean Davis, Houston Roughnecks
Safety is arguably the most pressing need on the Packers roster, and Sean Davis has plenty of NFL experience. A former second-round pick for the Pittsburgh Steelers, he's also played for Washington, the Indianapolis Colts, Cincinnati Bengals, and New England Patriots. After a year away from the NFL, he decided to give it another chance and signed with the Houston Roughnecks. He leads the league in interceptions among safeties, with three, and also has had 16 tackles.
K Dominik Eberle, Seattle Sea Dragons
Kicking is a difficult proposition, and sometimes players take time to develop. That might be Eberle's case. Born in Germany, the kicker spent some time with the Packers last offseason, but was released before training camp. He's played two NFL games, one for the Houston Texans in 2021 and one for the Detroit Lions last year, both as a replacement kicker, converting three out of four field goals and seven out of nine extra points. In the XFL for the Seattle Sea Dragons, Eberle has converted 12 field goals (1st in the league) in 13 attempts, including a 54-yarder. He has the best field goal percentage among qualified kickers. Right now, Parker White is the only kicker on the Packers roster, so it's inevitable the team will add another piece to create a competition if Mason Crosby doesn't re-sign.
Photo: Steven Bisig-USA TODAY Sports
-----------------------------
Wendell Ferreira covers the Green Bay Packers for Zone Coverage and Cheesehead TV. He is a Brazilian journalist with over a decade of experience covering the NFL, soccer, NBA, and MMA. Follow him on twitter at @wendellfp
__________________________
PLEASE SUBSCRIBE TO OUR CHEESEHEAD NATION WEEKLY NEWSLETTER HERE.
__________________________




Comments (14)
RCPackerFan
April 04, 2023 at 12:13 pm
Butler is an intriguing player. I haven't watched any of the XFL, but Butler is a big target. He could potentially be a fit to play a role similar to what Lazards role was in the offense. The mauler type.
KnockTheSnotOutOfYou
April 04, 2023 at 03:42 pm
Agreed!
Don't recall exactly when he came out (seems like just about 3 years ago), but I was really high on him and wanted the Pack to draft him.
jannesbjornson
April 04, 2023 at 06:14 pm
Scrub Talk...
egbertsouse
April 04, 2023 at 12:14 pm
How about the Packers sign good players rather than washouts from the minor leagues? What a novel concept?
Packerpasty
April 04, 2023 at 12:23 pm
exactly...other divisional teams adding pieces Packers are subtracting...dont think this will end well for at least a few years...
ko40489
April 04, 2023 at 04:03 pm
Gutey will always keep his draft picks over undrafted free agents even if the latter perform better. Seems he prefers to compound an error in his drafting rather than fix it when he has the opportunity. Only to cut the draft pick a few years later. Just look at his 2018 draft class--only one player still on the roster. Not a good way to build a team. Those are the guys who should now be coming into their prime.
Coldworld
April 04, 2023 at 12:28 pm
Canella not being brought back in the PS was a mild surprise to me, at least as a pass catching option. I don’t recall him showing much ability as a blocker. I’m wondering if there’s something that persuaded us to move on even when in season slots opened.
Butler, Davis and Harris would be worth a camp look on minimum contracts, but these guys are now on teams’ radars, so the one or two that really shine may get more than that.
Whether and what the chances are that any would break through is a good question. Few CFL players make it and by December last year, the only USFL players on an NFL roster were WR/KR KaVontae Turpin (Generals-Cowboys) and , technically, DE Chris Odom on preseason season ending Injured Reserve with Cleveland. Odom has bounced around the league for a while. There were 20 odd on practice squads, and that probably indicative of the most likely upside.
Would I say no to adding a couple for camp? No. Do I see any helping this year? The odds are strongly against it apparently.
splitpea1
April 04, 2023 at 01:50 pm
You forgot about our own (well, not anymore) Abernathy, who was called up in December.
PatrickGB
April 04, 2023 at 01:13 pm
I like the out of the box thinking. Let’s see how they do in training camp. Sometimes players just need a chance and good coaching.
BirdDogUni
April 04, 2023 at 01:46 pm
"Good Coaching?"
"Good Coaching?"
Said in Jim Mora's voice...
PatrickGB
April 05, 2023 at 07:09 am
Ha! Good point
HarryHodag
April 04, 2023 at 02:26 pm
I've watched a lot of the XFL this season and I agree with Wendell's analysis, especially McCarron. He will never be confused Tom Brady but he easily could be a veteran back up and I bet he will work cheap.
The rest, like Cannella, are a toss up. If they have NFL experience they will stand out during this level of play. But they aren't in the NFL for a variety of reasons. One exception could be the kicker Eberle. Kicking is kicking and you have to do essentially the same thing be it in the NFL, CFL, or lower level college ball. The goal posts and the distances stay roughly the same.
relleum61
April 04, 2023 at 03:38 pm
We need 90 bodies to start training camp. These 7 have been getting reps, experience and a chance to improve their craft. These 7 (or others) plus another bunch of UFDA's (plus the draft picks) will compete for the final 53 + practice squad. Give them a "go" and see where the chips fall. It can only raise the level of competition on the bottom.
That said, McCarron could function as a decent/cheap back-up qb and he does have experience in the Shanahan system. Eberle could be a "camp leg" and he does have (unlike the current kicker on the roster) recent game experience.
BuckyBadger
April 04, 2023 at 04:25 pm
You can sign off people practice squads that are better then these guys. Bring them into camp but if you think you will find much you are fooling yourself.