Packers’ Roster Gelling, Still Jiggly in Spots
Key decisions remain in countdown to cutdown Tuesday.

Packers backups brought significantly more effort and focus to Lambeau on Saturday against the Ravens than they had in Denver last week, and none too soon, with teams needing to get down to 53-man rosters by tomorrow (Tuesday).
I’ll let others do full-roster predictions, especially since it is highly doubtful the roster set Tuesday will be what we see in Brazil for opening night a week from Friday. Green Bay’s front office still has several decisions to make, and will want to peruse cuts made by other teams before and after the cutdowns. But here’s where some of the key position battles stand:
Backup QB: Although both played better than last week, neither Michael Pratt nor Sean Clifford grabbed the job and made it theirs. Pratt had the better numbers in the 30-7 win over Baltimore, but neither man broke a passer rating of 80, and there were some rough patches against Ravens backups. There is a lot of buzz that the Packers will make a move, either keeping both and adding a free-agent QB, or cutting one and replacing him. I lean toward keeping Pratt, as Clifford just lacks the upside, but I much prefer seasoned vets backing up franchise QBs, because if the latter gets hurt a developmental quarterback can ruin your season. Green Bay has rarely gone this route, but I am intrigued by the possibility of Ryan Tannehill. The Tennessee Titans added Tannehill in 2019 and he took them to the playoffs the season after Matt Lafleur came to Green Bay. Tannehill no doubt wants a shot to start with salary to match, but if no decent opportunities arise I’d urge the Packers to try to get him to carry the clipboard on a one-year deal. Neither Pratt nor Clifford would be able to save the Packers if they had to start, so Green Bay is playing the football equivalent of Russian Roulette with the most important position in the game.
Kicker: Both Anders Carlson and Greg Joseph were much better than last week, a welcome relief though I remain uncertain how much to trust it. I suspect Carlson will keep the job because of Rich Bisaccia’s love for him, but it could still go either way. Australian Alex Hale is in the mix, but there has been little reason to consider him an upgrade. Perhaps a good cut candidate will come free, but right now it feels like the Packers and their fans are going to have to sweat every kick no matter who wins the job, which is a giant ugh.
Offensive line: This issue here is primarily backups. The team seems set with Rasheed Walker, Elgton Jenkins, Josh Meyers, Sean Rhyan and Zach Tom from left to right, though Rhyan is a bit of a question mark. Jordan Morgan isn’t going anywhere as a first-round pick, but where he lands is still up in the air. Andre Dillard and Jacob Monk appear locked into backup slots. That leaves the question of whether the team carries nine or 10 O-linemen, with Royce Newman, Caleb Jones, Travis Glover and Kadeem Telfort in the mix for the last one or two slots. The team might opt for Newman’s experience, at a backup spot or starting at right guard, but I’m hoping I finally have a chance to do my best Jerry Seinfeld impersonation and say “Goodbye, Newman.” I’ve been practicing, because the man is not up to the task. Let’s take our chances with the kids, Mr. Gutekunst, or find someone who was cut that can play the position while also addressing the need for better run blocking by the O-line room overall.
Defensive end: This is among the most fascinating situations on the team, although it’s more in the realm of a good problem to have. Out of almost nowhere, Arron Mosby has made a strong case for a roster spot as a fifth DE behind Rashan Gary, Preston Smith, Lukas Van Ness and Kingsley Enagbare. Brenton Cox is also in the mix, and one or the other (or both) will likely find themselves on the practice squad. It’s not clear whether Green Bay wants to keep five DEs, and some of it might depend on whether the team keeps more than four D linemen. If not, Colby Wooden could be a roster casualty, though it’s rare when the Packers cut such a high draft pick so early.
Linebacker: Another positive situation, with Kristian Welch suddenly looking like a lot more than just a special teams ace. I’m rooting hard for his addition, in part because I’m not sold on the LB room beyond a hopefully improved Quay Walker and an unproven high draft pick in Edgerrin Cooper. Welch just seems to have high football IQ and keen instincts for the ball.
Cornerback 5: It gets thin fast after Alexander, Stokes, Valentine and Keisean Nixon, who should be slot only. I have serious concerns about depth in this group, especially given the injury histories of Alexander and Stokes. Kalen King has not looked quite ready, and is a better practice squad candidate. This is another case where I’d be combing the waiver wire.
Lastly, wideouts 5 and maybe 6: After Reed, Doubs, Wicks and Watson, will it be Dubose? Heath? Melton? And will they keep 5 or 6? Flip whatever coins you like. Might come down to who has the best chance of not clearing waivers. This isn’t one that makes a big difference to the Packers’ fortunes. If I was the GM? Heath just gets open in clutch situations, and I like Melton’s size/speed combination.
GPG.
PLEASE SUBSCRIBE TO OUR CHEESEHEAD NATION WEEKLY NEWSLETTER HERE.
__________________________
Jonathan Krim grew up in New York but got hooked on the Packers — and on hating the Cowboys — watching the Ice Bowl as a young child. He blames bouts of unhappiness in his late teens on Dan Devine. A journalist for several decades who now lives in California, he enjoys trafficking in obscure cultural references, lame dad jokes and occasionally preposterous takes. Jonathan is a Packers shareholder, and insists on kraut with his brats. You can follow Jonathan on twitter at @Jkrim.
__________________________




Comments (24)
mrtundra
August 26, 2024 at 07:29 am
What about the Safety room? McKinney, Bullard, Evan Williams, Anthony Johnson, Jr are probably the top four here. Who do they keep out of Zayne Anderson, Kitan Oladapo and Benny Sapp III, if any? My guess is Oladapo stays but goes to the PS. Has Anderson or Sapp III even earned a spot on the PS?
Another lock, for the LB room, would appear to be Ty'Ron Hopper, who has shown up in Camp and preseason.
TKWorldWide
August 26, 2024 at 07:39 am
Good points.
And the current injuries at RB muddy that room up as well.
Coldworld
August 26, 2024 at 09:27 am
Sapp seems the forgotten man. He played well in very limited chances. I think Oladapo makes the PS, I’m not sure that they keep 2 safeties there.
Anderson might get and take a PS offer elsewhere with less young depth above him at S. He had a pretty decent camp on D for a depth player and is a known ST standout.
LambeauPlain
August 26, 2024 at 10:32 am
My bet is Oladapo joins Xavier, Bullard, Williams and Johnson Jr. All 5 have ability to play slot and fit in productively in Nickel and Dime. I believe bringing in Safeties vs CBs is more likely for the dime this year.
Oladapo was very productive at Oregon state and a team Captain (which Gutey values highly). He was hampered early with the injury (Packers knew he would be delayed on draft day) and is only now climbing the NFL learning curve. I have a strong feeling a Safety needy team would grab him and let him complete the learning on their 53.
Coldworld
August 26, 2024 at 10:42 am
I’m not sure AJJ or Oladapo have shown an ability to play in the slot. Oladapo in particular would be a surprise if he could.
LambeauPlain
August 26, 2024 at 11:50 am
AJJ has those CB skills from college ball and Oladapo is just getting started. At OSU he routinely and successfully covered TEs (realize it is different from slot WRs)...and he seems more talented in pass coverage near the LOS. He's probably not best suited at post S.
Hafley stated one of his goals for the Safeties are to use them interchangeably based on match ups including the slot.
I have not been this excited for the Safeties since the Butler, Robinson days.
TKWorldWide
August 26, 2024 at 12:42 pm
Yes, I see Oladapo in the slot in a zone coverage, but not in man to man vs those slippery slot receivers.
LeotisHarris
August 26, 2024 at 02:14 pm
Indeed. Kid has all the makings of an Intercontinental Champion, but *The* Belt will always remain out of his reach,
TKWorldWide
August 26, 2024 at 03:50 pm
Worst thing that can happen when you jerk the curtain is the crowd gets quiet.
Way too many crickets out there.
GregC
August 26, 2024 at 08:35 am
The question is not whether they keep 5 or 6 WRs, it's whether they keep 6 or 7. They kept 7 two years ago. I think Heath is WR #6 and Dubose gets cut, but they could very well keep DuBose.
Arron Mosby has been good, but he's also been lucky. On the strip sack, nobody blocked him, and he hit the QB just as he cocked his arm to throw. The interception was thrown right to him. Kudos to him for catching it, but as a DE, that's not likely to happen again. He looks more like a linebacker than a DE. I'm still leaning toward keeping Brenton Cox and letting Mosby go.
Hard to see Christian Welch sticking unless they keep 6 LBs. Eric Wilson is a very good special teams player, and I'm looking for the rookies Cooper and Hopper to excel on special teams as well.
Coldworld
August 26, 2024 at 09:32 am
Did you see that interception? I know a lot of players with regular coverage responsibilities who do not make that catch. Sorry, I couldn’t disagree more on that. What about his plays in the other games?
If they keep a 5th DE, I believe it should be Mosby. He had more impact than Cox, brings more versatility to the table and plays STs, which Cox does not. The route to being active for a 5th DE on this squad where Wooden and Brooks can also go outside, is ST contribution and bringing something different that Hafley wants to use in sub packages.
They could also decide that an ILB can play that role, for example, Hopper, and shift the spot for Welch (who could also) or Anderson, though I’d rather Rochell handles his likely ST role.
GregC
August 26, 2024 at 09:55 am
That was a really nice interception by Mosby. He showed good hands there. I just don't think an ability to catch interceptions is high on the list of qualifications for a defensive end. Mosby has made plays all through camp though. On the other hand, Cox has looked good at times as well. It is a tough decision between the two of them. I thought Cox has been playing on special teams, but I can't find anything about that on the Internet.
Coldworld
August 26, 2024 at 10:43 am
Cox is an undersized additional DE. He’s made plays, but would he get snaps over Wooden or Brooks? Unlike Mosby he doesn’t play STs. Mosby has had I think as many sacks in games as he has in preseason, plays STs and looks like he can drop into coverage. Not many LBs react and make a hands catch like that. It was impressive.
Hafley may like that situational option. He could of course use an ILB perhaps instead and let that spot be filled elsewhere. On merit, however, I go with the difference maker, and Mosby has made critical plays happen in each game, albeit late until Saturday. Cox’s successes have also come late though.
LambeauPlain
August 26, 2024 at 11:18 am
I see both Welch and Mosby making the 53. If you don't reward production what is the point of having a preseason? Those two Packers destroyed the Ravens offense several times. That was special.
Welch has great instincts and is relentless. As CW stated, that INT was impressive awareness and coordination while being in the right spot to make a play. Welch's on field awareness and coordination are attributes you want in a LB. Wilson better watch out.
Mosby is a tougher call but I would not assign his great production on Saturday to "Lady Luck". In the NFL you make your own luck. The strip sack TD was a great speed play just a split second before the QB threw. On his INT, the play called for him to drop into the D's shallow right zone behind LOS and he made the play! How many times have we seen those "gimmes" dropped?
Hafley loves turnovers and the players make them.
I don't see Cox being grabbed for another team's 53...he has flashed and has some bend on the edge but still not consistent.
LBs: Walker, McDuffie, Cooper, Hopper, Wilson, Welch (instead of more TEs for STs, LBs this year)
DTs: Clark, Slaton, Wyatt, Brooks, Wooden (also subbing in at DE)
DE's: Gary, Preston, Van Ness, Enagbare, Mosby.
10 on the DL as I expect frequent rotations to keep the big boys fresh bringing their QB pressure cooker.
That's 16 players for the rooms that man the front 7...they had 17 last season.
And of course Gutey will surprise me.
HawkPacker
August 26, 2024 at 08:37 am
The kicking position is still a bit of a problem.
I would like them to keep Carlson, but every FG I have seen him make this preseason has just made it inside the uprights. I only watched 2 games and did not see the Denver game. When Joseph kicks the FG's the ones I have seen have been right down the middle.
I know if it is just inside the uprights it is good but they look so close to missing that it concerns me.
At times Joseph looks pretty good but when the weather turns cold, his history at Lambeau has not been good.
Coldworld
August 26, 2024 at 08:53 am
Wooden has had one of the best preseasons. He’s not going to be a casualty.
The best 5th DE has been Mosby. If we keep one he’s it he one most deserving. He also adds a ST capability.
I do not understand your fears at CB depth. Rochell has been one of the best graded corners in both games he played and in camp. Ballentine proved more than capable last season and can play some slot, if needed, along with the rookie safeties. King has shown potential inside too.
Cheezehead72
August 26, 2024 at 09:06 am
I agree that they need to keep Pratt over Clifford for the same reason. Clifford has all the indications that he has plateaued. Now I would not be surprised if the release both figuring that both of them will not be taken off of waivers. I bet both of them clear waivers as no team (other than the Vikings) would want to sign them to their 53. Then the Packers get both on the PS and we can move a player to IR.
Joseph is gone. He is no better than Carlson and he counts more to the salary cap. I really do not care which one they keep. Both are a liability. I hope whoever they keep will get better.
I can see the Packers keeping 7 WRs. But I am leaning on them keeping 6. Melton is #5 and DeBose is #6. Most teams are going to sign their own WRs because it takes awhile to get them in the system.
stockholder
August 26, 2024 at 10:10 am
I'm going to disagree with you at QB.
Also several other positions.
Even Kicker.
Point:
This team went deep in the playoffs.
Replacing somebody due to upside won't work.
Not with young players and a young roster.
Mistake: Upside has No business in a play-off team.
Chemistry Does.!
Clifford and Carlson should retain their positions
If they can't exceed their rookie performance.
Then yes- Replace them.
Performance over upside now.
LambeauPlain
August 26, 2024 at 11:35 am
Poor Luke Tenuta. He "can't get no respect, I tell ya!" He rarely gets mentioned...even in cut down discussions.
I also believe the experiments in the Land of the Giants need to redirect. Rookie Glover has outplayed the veterans at T and he still has a ways to go but with more upside. Telfort, Tenuta, and Jones would all probably make the PS anyway...and only Jones deserves that spot. "Goodbye Neeewman!" should also happen as Monk, Rhyan, and Morgan are all upgrades at IOL.
James Campen should have solid input to Team Gutey regarding best options with the Ts waived tomorrow...maybe another swing T/Gs too, if they keep 10. Dillard does not inspire confidence and now he's dinged up.
gsd3
August 26, 2024 at 12:14 pm
I would look at adding Spencer Shrader and cut Carlson.
They could always add him to the squad.
Coldworld
August 26, 2024 at 12:31 pm
Schrader is as much, if not more, of a project than Carlson. If a guy like him clears waivers then I could see a PS addition, though I doubt they keep 3 as in-season rules limit practice time significantly, but Hales is a long term punt anyway.
LambeauPlain
August 26, 2024 at 01:16 pm
And Hale gets to add to the PS, not take up a PS spot as an international exemption.
Packitin
August 26, 2024 at 04:07 pm
"It gets thin fast after Alexander, Stokes, Valentine and Keisean Nixon, who should be slot only. I have serious concerns about depth in this group..."
Corey Ballentine did a more-than-respectable job last season, and Robert Rochelle has had a good camp. Plus, Bullard can man the slot if Nixon falters. How much more depth do you want?
Packitin
August 26, 2024 at 04:12 pm
Shouldn't we be rushing to sign recently-waived QB Rocky Lombardi? And G Wyatt Davis (Grandson of Willie)?
K Matthew Wright was just waived by Pit.