For the Packers: Same Ending, Different Year
Packers quarterback Jordan Love walks off the field after a 31-27 loss the Bears on Saturday night. Love had a playoff career-best 323 yards and 4 touchdowns.

The theme of Green Bay Packers playoff football the last 30 years has been mostly excruciating playoff exits, mixed around two Super Bowl championships and a few blowout losses. Modern-day Packers fans have been lucky to watch their team play in three Super Bowls since the last 30 years, winning two of them.
However, when it comes to playoff football, lately it’s been almost the same movie every year, with the same ending.
Whether it’s blown 4th quarter leads, walkoff losses in regulation or overtime, or underperforming against a lesser opponent in January after a season filled with promise.
Since 1993, when Ron Wolf and Mike Holmgren made their first playoff appearance, the Packers have had 25 playoff appearances, compiling a 24-23 record.
During Holmgren’s tenure the Packers were 9-5 in the playoffs from 1993 to 1998. Under Mike Sherman, Green Bay was 2-4 in the playoffs from 2001 to 2004. Mike McCarthy was next, as the Packers were 10-6 in playoff games from 2007 to 2016. And in the Matt LaFleur era, Green Bay is 3-6 in playoff games starting in 2019.
| Coach | Years | Record | Best Win | Toughest Loss |
| Mike Holmgren | 1993-1998 | 9-5 | Super Bowl XXXI - d. NE 35-21 | Super Bowl XXXII - lost to Den 31-23 |
| Mike Sherman | 2001-2004 | 2-4 | 2003 Wild Card - d. Sea 33-27(ot) | 2003 NFC Div Playoffs- lost to Phi 20-17(ot) |
| Mike McCarthy | 2007, 2009-2016 | 10-6 | Super Bowl XLV - d. Pit 31-25 | 2014 NFC Ch Gm - lost to Sea 28-22(ot) |
| Matt LaFleur | 2019-2021, 2023-25 | 3-6 | NFC Div Playoffs - d. LAR 32-18 | 2020 NFC Ch Gm - lost to TB 31-26 |
The team has had multiple playoff wins in five of those years (1995, 1996, 1997, 2010, 2016). However, despite all the success, what’s stood out for the past three decades is the way the team has departed the playoffs via heartbreak, far too often.
1- 2014, I don't know how you top that, given stakes
2- 2007 NFCCG
3- 2003 Div -4th and 26 (or 1)
4- SB 32
5- 2025 WC CHI
6- 2021 Div SF
7- 1998 WC SF - Rice fumbled/TO
8- 2009 WC AZ https://t.co/JKdN2qK4iI— Jason Perone (@JasonPerone) January 12, 2026
Starting with the Super Bowl XXXII loss, I put together my list of the worst Packers playoff losses since 1997.
10. 2021 NFC Divisional Playoff - SF 13, GB 10
Losing a home playoff game to the rival 49ers in what seemed like a team that was going to finally get back to a Super Bowl. The Packers scored on their first drive from an AJ Dillon touchdown run. But a fumble on the next drive by Marcedes Lewis was a sign of what the rest of the game would be like for the offense. Despite not allowing an offensive touchdown, a walk-off field goal by Robbie Gould ended the #1 seed’s season.
9. 2009 NFC Wild Card - Arz 51, GB 45 (ot)
Despite this team winning the Super Bowl the next season, this loss still hurts 16 years later. Aaron Rodgers missed a touchdown pass to Greg Jennings on the first play of overtime from going over 500 yards with five touchdowns in this playoff shootout. However, three plays later, the highest-scoring playoff game in history was ended on a defensive score. Despite being a round earlier than the 2015 rematch, this game felt like a tougher loss based on the potential of this team (which we saw in 2010 and 2011).
8. 2011 NFC Divisional Playoff - NYG 37, GB 20
The highest-scoring team in Packers history and the only team in franchise history to win 15 games, went out in shocking fashion in their first playoff game to the same Giants team that pops up on the list a few games later. Even though this was not a last-second loss, the pain was not seeing this team have a chance at consecutive Super Bowls. MVP Aaron Rodgers and his great receivers picked the wrong day to be off their games against the Giants.
7. 2025 NFC Wild Card - Chi 31, GB 27
Put this loss a little lower than some would just based on the way this season was playing out. Without guys like Parsons, Kraft, Tom and Wyatt, does the 2025 team make a deep run in the playoffs had it got by the rival Bears? It is the largest blown lead on this lead, being up 21-3 at the half and then losing a heartbreaker for the second time in four weeks at Soldier Field will make this a very tough offseason.
6. 1998 NFC Wild Card - SF 30, GB 27
To Packers fans this is the “Jerry Rice fumbled game.” A few minutes earlier, Brett Favre connected with Antonio Freeman in what seemed like the 4th straight playoff win over the rival 49ers. However, in both Holmgren and Reggie White’s last games as Packers, the defense couldn’t hold a 27-23 lead. Still believe if they win this game, they were eyeing redemption showdowns with both the Vikings and Broncos that year.
5. 2007 NFC Championship - NYG 23, GB 20(ot)
Brett Favre’s last pass a Packer being an overtime interception will be the lasting image of this game. Played in subzero temperatures, the Packers struggled to move the ball outside of a Donald Driver 90-yard touchdown catch and run. A win in this game would have set up the Packers with the undefeated Patriots in Super Bowl XLII.
4. 2003 NFC Divisional Playoff - Phi 20, GB 17(ot)
This game could rank higher on the pain list despite not being a championship game or Super Bowl. The Packers outplayed the eventual 2004 NFC champions for 58 minutes, as Ahman Green had his second big running game (156 yards) against the Eagles that season. However, Mike Sherman not going for a 4th & 1 with just over 2 minutes to go would do in this season. It also ended another possible Super Bowl rematch with the Patriots (another theme on the list; see 2007, 2011, 2014).
3. 2020 NFC Championship - TB 31, GB 26
It wasn’t a walk-off loss like the overtime or last-second field goal losses, but the 2020 team was the Packers best regular-season team since the 2011 team. Once again, Aaron Rodgers won MVP and his team led the league in scoring (also happened in 2011 and 2014). However, a dreadful five-minute stretch of gametime had the Packers go from trailing 14-10 to 28-10, which was too much to overcome against Tom Brady and the Bucs, despite Brady throwing three second-half interceptions. Five years later, the Packers still haven’t gotten back to the championship game.
2. Super Bowl XXXII - Den 31, GB 24
The Packers once again won 13 games, were double-digit favorites and then scored a touchdown after the game’s opening kickoff. It seemed like a path toward another repeat, 30 years later, however two first half Brett Favre turnovers, not running Dorsey Levens more and the inability to stop the run led to the ending of the NFC’s 13-game Super Bowl winning streak. Because the game was almost 30 years ago, it seems forgotten as one of the best Super Bowls, but when the caliber of the two teams, quarterbacks and head coaches is considered, it was one of the best played Super Bowls of all time. Unfortunately the Packers were on the losing end of this game.
1. 2014 NFC Championship - Sea 28, GB 22(ot)
For most franchises, a Super Bowl loss beats any other losses, but that’s how bad the No. 1 loss was. The Packers had a 13-0 lead after the first quarter against the defending champions who also had the league’s best defense of the entire decade of the 2010’s. They were able to get five takeaways, four of them being interceptions of Russell Wilson. But the 16-0 lead in the third quarter was not a big enough lead as a fake field goal for a touchdown, a kneeling down on a 4th quarter interception by Morgan Burnett, the fateful onside kick recovery by the Seahawks and Haha Clinton-Dix’s misplay of a two-point conversion would all lead to the biggest collapse in franchise history. Another team that the Rodgers-led offense was the NFL’s highest scoring and was just another win away from a second Super Bowl championship in five years.
Honorable Mention: 2013 SF 23, GB 20; 2015 Arz 26, GB 20 (ot); 2023 SF 24, GB
PLEASE SUBSCRIBE TO OUR CHEESEHEAD NATION WEEKLY NEWSLETTER HERE.
__________________________
Mitch McLaughlin is a Packers fan and shareholder residing in Sacramento, California. He will be writing Packers stories each week on Cheesehead TV. He can be found on Twitter: @McLaughlinMitch
__________________________




Comments (24)
TarynsEyes
January 12, 2026 at 06:11 pm
Love was able to take advantage of an overaggressive Johnson (a bad habit from his Lions days) giving him great field position and two TDs on two 4th down failures. It doesn't make him elite, and neither does the end total of stats. His opportunity for elite speak was the second half, where he stepped aside for a QB who actually wants to earn elite status without the need of stats, but his play on the field, and Williams, certainly did so.
Elite QB's can carry and cover up issues, Love, regretfully, simply exposes them to an even higher/clearer viewing. Love will have his moments, which really means, at this point, he's the luckier blind-squirrel when it comes to finding nuts.
Are there more reasons why he gets a nut or excuses why he doesn't get more?
Coldworld
January 13, 2026 at 11:11 am
It’s a virtual myth that QBs blow away teams with sheer brilliance against the run of play in a Super Bowl. There have been less than one handful of performances where that can be argued. Even less when their OL wasn’t winning. A great QB makes a few wow plays in playoff games and doesn’t otherwise hold his team back. The rest is done by the team around them executing and not missing assignments or tackles or dropping passes.
In the playoffs, it’s often one big play from somewhere that separates teams and thus it’s heavily on coaches to exploit weaknesses better than their opponent and set up their players mentally and schematically to win, including their QB.
The Playoffs are about mindset and discipline more than great plays. They are about finding and exploiting more weaknesses than opponents. If they do, then it’s about being ruthless and efficient.
All playoff teams can be good, put them away. That was what Brady and Bellicheck did so well. Love is perfectly capable of filling that role given a smart game plan and time. I’ve watched Brady melt enough eleven his line was overwhelmed, Rodgers too, Mahomes, anyone. I’ve watched great QBs be prevented from being great by the calls.
As one generally claiming to be the voice of realism, you are seemingly way off base with your expectations of what Love needs to be to win it all and probably on the degree of blame you assign him for the last exit. The fault here is not his. Sorry.
Where you might be right is that bird not good enough to win it with this organization of ours as currently led. However, I don’t know that anyone is or has been. That’s the real problem. Certainly, in this offense, he’s often having to overcome a design that minimizes his strengths, or at least the chance to do special things.
This is a run based conservative offense that runs relatively few actual deeper targets while relying on one aon one solo deep routes for big plays. Ideal for Willis, with his mobility. A waste of Love potentially. In any case, behind that line as it played in the second half no QB was going to excel (against a not frightening DL too), even when we were not failing to run on them, except by switching to a rapid release O, which LaFleur failed to call route trees for.
Love is fine, the environment he’s in is just not conducive. Unless the team faces that, no traditional QB is saving them them. Cap and talent aside, we should keep Willis if we insist on keeping LaFleur. That is one reason why we should remove LaFleur, Love is a better pure QB and likely a better QB for much longer. He needs an offense that accepts that not one that Willis was born for. A snapshot of what is wrong with the leadership around him.
Rebelgb
January 13, 2026 at 11:46 am
I wish I could get you to rewatch the 2nd half against the Bears. Then id like you to tell me how a QB under constant pressure, with no pocket to move around in, and missed blocking assignments in key plays, is going to win a football game by himself?
During the same rewatch id like you to also pay attention to the pocket Williams had around him when dropping back in the pocket in the 2nd half. He could have had a grill out in the pocket. If Love had been given Williams pocket in the 2nd half, this game would have been a Packer blowout.
KenEllis
January 12, 2026 at 06:15 pm
And now MLF will get paid a lot more $$$ to continue leading the Packers to 2nd or 3rd place finishes, 7th seeds, and 1 and done playoff appearances.
We do what we do in Green Bay and that means we always get to watch other franchise compete for the Lombardi Trophy on Super Bowl Sunday.
dblbogey
January 12, 2026 at 11:46 pm
Watching the playoff games, I discovered an amazing truth. You need to have a really good offensive line, and you need a real good defensive line. This year's group was bad, and needs an overhaul. The special teams has been a low priority for decades and costs us every year. Draft a kick returner, if there's a stud placekicker, draft him. Fire Bisaccia. Upgrade a few coaching positions. This team didn't seem to have the confidence or will to finish games, that needs to change.
Oxymoron 3339
January 13, 2026 at 04:53 am
We have a slightly above average GM. Can’t win a SB with that.
TarynsEyes
January 12, 2026 at 06:39 pm
Has any QB beat a team in the SB, and then win an SB with the team he had beaten?
Rodgers beat Pitt, and now has a possible chance to win with Pitt.
Anyone know?
dblbogey
January 12, 2026 at 11:48 pm
fortunately, or sadly, depending on your view of Rodgers, he won't be playing next week. I wonder if he'll try to come back next year - he seems to love the attention and competition.
Oxymoron 3339
January 13, 2026 at 04:54 am
No and Pitt had no chance last night. Texans are darn good, Pitt is seriously flawed.
Coldworld
January 13, 2026 at 11:21 am
As far as I’m aware no, not as a starter on a Super Bowl team. I think Goff might be the only one who has won a playoff game against a team he had previously started for in the playoffs. McMahon won a ring as Favre’s back up, in a game where the Packers beat his former team, but I don’t think he took the field.
jms
January 12, 2026 at 06:41 pm
Whatever they end up paying LaFleur, it will be less than what Harbaugh will demand. At what point does the track record in the playoffs have an impact on decision making?
From what is being said about the coaching situation in Green Bay,
track record and the constant meltdowns mean little to nothing.
TarynsEyes
January 12, 2026 at 07:08 pm
It's the saying, You have to be in it to win it, and it's true, but first round losses is like buying a ticket, getting a seat for a show that already played. The MLF era is like having that seat, and knowing how the movie ends, but you feel afraid to not buy one because it might end differently. Insanity, maybe, but insanity seems to be what's prevailing, in a lot of mindsets, these days, and hopefully for not much longer in many of them also.
Coldworld
January 13, 2026 at 11:26 am
I have no problem not buying tickets. If they keep LaFleur and this structure, I’m already at peace with disinvesting. Love the Packers, love football, but have no doubt on the course and no wish to suffer through it as an invested team fan.
Even in the dark days of McCarthy’s demise and Ball ruined roster, nothing felt nearly so inevitably futile as watching yet another season of organizational denial and entropy under this lot of that’s what comes to pass.
Lphill
January 12, 2026 at 07:18 pm
Groundhog Day continues
JohnnyLogan
January 12, 2026 at 10:06 pm
What would an honest poll of the Green Bay fanbase show right now—re-sign LaFleur or move on? This season has been a grind to endure, not something to enjoy. Too many bad performances, and even the wins felt joyless and labored. The answer wouldn’t be close: move on, immediately.
Management doesn’t have to take orders from the fans, but it also can’t pretend fan sentiment is meaningless. What they’re doing by resigning Le Fleur, instead, is alienating an already battered fanbase—sending people into the offseason frustrated, angry, and with no real belief that anything is going to change. That isn’t noise. That’s the erosion of goodwill, trust, and engagement. And when an organization stops caring about that, it’s usually a sign that complacency has set in at the top.
Oxymoron 3339
January 13, 2026 at 04:55 am
I think it’s more about the GM than the coach.
Since'61
January 12, 2026 at 10:10 pm
25 playoff appearances and only 3 SB appearances. This while having 2 of the greatest QBs to ever play in the league. Only 5 of the 25 seasons with multiple playoff wins tells us even more about the systemic problems of the Packers organization going back over the last 25 years. 3 of the 5 multiple playoff win seasons were during the Holmgren era which means only 2 seasons since then have the Packers had multiple playoff wins..
The Packers have lost playoff games in just about every conceivable manner.
IMO most of the losses have been due to either holes at positions (e.g., the OL, DL, and others) that went unaddressed for the entire season or coaches who were kept for longer than they should have been specifically on defense and on STs. These are systemic organizational issues. Injuries and poor drafting have also been contributing factors. Some terrible officiating has impacted playoff results but that is a league wide problem getting worse with every season.
At the least the Packers need to get back to a GM who has total control over all football operations as Ron Wolf had. The current structure has proven to be an ineffective approach to holding the GM or the HC accountable and needs to be corrected or we will continue to see seasons ending prematurely and maybe even failing to reach the playoffs. Thanks, Since '61
Oxymoron 3339
January 13, 2026 at 04:58 am
Wolf turned this franchise around and deserves tons of credit, but later failed to surround 4 with enough talent. Same with Ted. Gute hasn’t been as good as those two but somehow just good enough that we are stuck with him.
Rebelgb
January 13, 2026 at 11:51 am
YES YES YES!!
We absolutely need to return to the old leadership structure with the GM having total control of football operations.
Its maddening to me that Policy didnt make that happen the first week of his new tenure. It tells me he likes the idea of the power the current structure gives him and thats a bad sign to the start of his tenure.
vin0770
January 12, 2026 at 10:38 pm
Seven years and we’ve seen this show before. Pretty simple…what’s the definition of insanity?
dblbogey
January 12, 2026 at 11:52 pm
Watching Randy Wright as your QB and thinking you have a chance to win?
Oxymoron 3339
January 13, 2026 at 04:59 am
Ha. Love Randy but you’re right.
Lphill
January 13, 2026 at 06:37 am
lets not give Hafley a free pass either , leads in all the recent losses ? maybe he's not the guy
Major Snafu
January 13, 2026 at 06:59 pm
Gee I wonder why? Came with no d coaching experience, grabbed
Barry's play book and ran with bend don't break. He couldn't bluzt because he
Needed the line backers dropping into coverage to fill those gaping holes.
Ya that didn't work .